Legal And Ethical Challenges Of Artificial Intelligence From An International Law Perspective

Legal And Ethical Challenges Of Artificial Intelligence From An International Law Perspective Book in PDF, ePub and Kindle version is available to download in english. Read online anytime anywhere directly from your device. Click on the download button below to get a free pdf file of Legal And Ethical Challenges Of Artificial Intelligence From An International Law Perspective book. This book definitely worth reading, it is an incredibly well-written.

Legal and Ethical Challenges of Artificial Intelligence from an International Law Perspective

Themistoklis Tzimas
Legal and Ethical Challenges of Artificial Intelligence from an International Law Perspective Book PDF

Author : Themistoklis Tzimas
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 246 pages
File Size : 55,8 Mb
Release : 2021-07-30
Category : Law
ISBN : 9783030785857

Get Book

Legal and Ethical Challenges of Artificial Intelligence from an International Law Perspective by Themistoklis Tzimas Pdf

This book focuses on the legal regulation, mainly from an international law perspective, of autonomous artificial intelligence systems, of their creations, as well as of the interaction of human and artificial intelligence. It examines critical questions regarding both the ontology of autonomous AI systems and the legal implications: what constitutes an autonomous AI system and what are its unique characteristics? How do they interact with humans? What would be the implications of combined artificial and human intelligence? It also explores potentially the most important questions: what are the implications of these developments for collective security –from both a state-centered and a human perspective, as well as for legal systems? Why is international law better positioned to make such determinations and to create a universal framework for this new type of legal personality? How can the matrix of obligations and rights of this new legal personality be construed and what would be the repercussions for the international community? In order to address these questions, the book discusses cognitive aspects embedded in the framework of law, offering insights based on both de lege lata and de lege ferenda perspectives.

Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law

Abhivardhan
Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law Book PDF

Author : Abhivardhan
Publisher : BPB Publications
Page : 271 pages
File Size : 49,8 Mb
Release : 2019-09-17
Category : Computers
ISBN : 9789388511629

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law by Abhivardhan Pdf

Artificial Intelligence may be the disruptive tech to influence our lives, but in the end, it has its own species to grow, so let us not take it as something we use and leave.Ê DESCRIPTION The book enters with its first chapter providing a simple and legal backdrop of the idea behind AI Ethics and International Law, its references and some important analogies and conceptual ideas. Also, the first chapter introduces some problems and questions regarding AI for contemplation in the field of jurisprudence. The second chapter vividly focuses on the deeper aspect of Artificial Intelligence, and goes to the principled developments of pure international law, with special analysis of the conceptions of sovereignty, self_determination and human rights. The chapter explores the catchy world of design and technology and covers with the diversity of issues revolving Artificial Intelligence Ethics. The third chapter gets specific with International Law and paves on ways towards the idea of the Privacy Doctrine conceived by the author. The chapter also explores the conceptual propositions in the field of Artificial Intelligence and International Law and renders about the scope of culture as a part of the social ecosystem to affect artificial intelligence. The chapter also lays the origination of the idea of an AI as an Entity, with special examples. The fourth chapter is centric towards human rights, making the debate beyond the legal literature and pragmatizing about the corporate idea of innovation and customer experience in various tech companies and institutions. The final chapter digs deeper into the principles and realms of cosmopolitanism and globalization, giving ways to discover and embark upon the role of human empathy and understanding to solve the issues that disruptive technology renders in its canvas.Ê KEY FEATURES _ The book gives a lucid introduction to the idea of AI Ethics and its geopolitical implications.Ê _ The book is insightful for an academic understanding of AI Ethics in the concept of Legal Personality meant for every person, including professionals in the field of Law, Social Sciences and Technology Studies.Ê _ The book provides a special understanding and renders curiosity for readers to establish newer ideas and understand Artificial Intelligence from a socio_cultural scenario.Ê _ The book gives a cogent aspect of the relationship between Artificial Intelligence and International Law.Ê _ The book presents about an innovative and dimensional idea of Privacy with respect to AI in Legal Theory.Ê WHAT WILL YOU LEARN The reader will learn about artificial intelligence in the eyes of a social animal, beyond the technical aspect of it. It enables the reader to challenge the conventional understanding of artificial intelligence and gives a motivation to understand the deep connect that AI is capable to create with humans in its social, economic and cultural scenarios rendered. It also poses a sense of curiosity and humility for people to understand the legal and social role of disrupting tech whether they are in a developed country or a developing one.Ê WHO THIS BOOK IS FOR This book is based for students, academicians, educationists, professionals and policy researchers in the field of law, social sciences, management and technology to understand and get a special insight of artificial intelligence for mankind. It is also a good read for a layman audience to get into the idea of artificial intelligence ethics for their understanding and awareness.Ê Table of ContentsÊ 1. Introduction to Artificial intelligence and International law 2. The Basic Relationship: The Pragmatism 3. Legal visibility: DOCTRINE and Concept for AI 4. Beyond the Human Rights Discourse: A New Vision 5. Student Devices

Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law

Abhivardhan
Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law Book PDF

Author : Abhivardhan
Publisher : BPB Publications
Page : 178 pages
File Size : 48,7 Mb
Release : 2023-12-01
Category : Computers
ISBN : 9789355516220

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence Ethics and International Law by Abhivardhan Pdf

Unveiling the future: Navigating AI's Intricate Intersection with International Law – A Journey Beyond Hype and Governance KEY FEATURES ● Comprehensive overview of AI ethics and international law. ● Exploration of pragmatic approaches to AI governance. ● Navigation of global legal dynamics. ● Soft law recommendations for responsible AI development. DESCRIPTION Dive into the dynamic realm of AI governance with this groundbreaking book. Offering cutting-edge insights, it explores the intricate intersection of artificial intelligence and international law. Readers gain invaluable perspectives on navigating the evolving AI landscape, understanding global legal dynamics, and delving into the nuances of responsible AI governance. Packed with pragmatic approaches, the book is an essential guide for professionals, policymakers, and scholars seeking a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted challenges and opportunities presented by AI in the global legal arena. The book begins by examining the fundamental concepts of AI ethics and its recognition within international law. It then delves into the challenges of governing AI in a rapidly evolving technological landscape, highlighting the need for pragmatic and flexible approaches to AI regulation. Subsequent chapters explore the diverse perspectives on AI classification and recognition, from legal visibility frameworks to the ISAIL Classifications of Artificial Intelligence. The book also examines the far-reaching implications of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) and digital colonialism, addressing the ethical dilemmas and potential dangers of these emerging technologies. In conclusion, the book proposes a path toward self-regulation and offers soft law recommendations to guide the responsible development and deployment of AI. It emphasizes the importance of international cooperation and collaboration in addressing the ethical and legal challenges posed by AI, ensuring that AI's transformative power is harnessed for the benefit of all humanity. WHAT YOU WILL LEARN ● Understand AI's impact on global legal frameworks. ● Navigate complexities of AI governance and responsible practices. ● Explore innovative AI applications and economic dimensions. ● Grasp legal visibility, privacy doctrines, and classification methods. ● Assess the evolution from Narrow AI to AGI and digital colonialism. ● Gain insights into self-regulation and the future of AI. WHO THIS BOOK IS FOR This book is tailored for professionals, policymakers, and scholars seeking a comprehensive understanding of AI's intersection with international law. While no specific prerequisites are necessary, a foundational awareness of AI concepts and legal frameworks will enhance the reader's engagement with the material. TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION 1: Introduction 1. Artificial Intelligence and International Law SECTION 2: Technology Governance 2. Pragmatism in Governing AI 3. The Innovation and Economics of AI SECTION 3: Classification and Recognition of Artificial Intelligence 4. Legal Visibility 5. The Privacy Doctrine 6. The ISAIL Classifications of Artificial Intelligence SECTION 4: Artificial Intelligence in a Multi-polar World 7. AGI and Digital Colonialism 8. Self-Regulating the Future of AI

Law and Artificial Intelligence

Bart Custers,Eduard Fosch-Villaronga
Law and Artificial Intelligence Book PDF

Author : Bart Custers,Eduard Fosch-Villaronga
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 566 pages
File Size : 40,7 Mb
Release : 2022-07-05
Category : Law
ISBN : 9789462655232

Get Book

Law and Artificial Intelligence by Bart Custers,Eduard Fosch-Villaronga Pdf

This book provides an in-depth overview of what is currently happening in the field of Law and Artificial Intelligence (AI). From deep fakes and disinformation to killer robots, surgical robots, and AI lawmaking, the many and varied contributors to this volume discuss how AI could and should be regulated in the areas of public law, including constitutional law, human rights law, criminal law, and tax law, as well as areas of private law, including liability law, competition law, and consumer law. Aimed at an audience without a background in technology, this book covers how AI changes these areas of law as well as legal practice itself. This scholarship should prove of value to academics in several disciplines (e.g., law, ethics, sociology, politics, and public administration) and those who may find themselves confronted with AI in the course of their work, particularly people working within the legal domain (e.g., lawyers, judges, law enforcement officers, public prosecutors, lawmakers, and policy advisors). Bart Custers is Professor of Law and Data Science at eLaw - Center for Law and Digital Technologies at Leiden University in the Netherlands. Eduard Fosch-Villaronga is Assistant Professor at eLaw - Center for Law and Digital Technologies at Leiden University in the Netherlands.

Artificial Intelligence, Social Harms and Human Rights

Aleš Završnik,Katja Simončič
Artificial Intelligence Social Harms and Human Rights Book PDF

Author : Aleš Završnik,Katja Simončič
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 281 pages
File Size : 48,6 Mb
Release : 2023-01-12
Category : Law
ISBN : 9783031191497

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence, Social Harms and Human Rights by Aleš Završnik,Katja Simončič Pdf

T​his book critically explores how and to what extent artificial intelligence (AI) can infringe human rights and/or lead to socially harmful consequences and how to avoid these. The European Union has outlined how it will use big data, machine learning, and AI to tackle a number of inherently social problems, including poverty, climate change, social inequality and criminality. The contributors of this book argue that the developments in AI must take place in an appropriate legal and ethical framework and they make recommendations to ensure that harm and human rights violations are avoided. The book is split into two parts: the first addresses human rights violations and harms that may occur in relation to AI in different domains (e.g. border control, surveillance, facial recognition) and the second part offers recommendations to address these issues. It draws on interdisciplinary research and speaks to policy-makers and criminologists, sociologists, scholars in STS studies, security studies scholars and legal scholars.

Artificial Intelligence: Robot Law, Policy and Ethics

Nathalie Rébé
Artificial Intelligence Robot Law Policy and Ethics Book PDF

Author : Nathalie Rébé
Publisher : BRILL
Page : 262 pages
File Size : 46,9 Mb
Release : 2021-08-09
Category : Law
ISBN : 9789004458109

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence: Robot Law, Policy and Ethics by Nathalie Rébé Pdf

In Artificial Intelligence: Robot Law, Policy and Ethics, Dr. Nathalie Rébé discusses the legal and contemporary issues in relation to creating conscious robots. This book provides an in-depth analysis of the existing regulatory tools, as well as a new comprehensive framework for regulating Strong AI.

An Introductory Guide to Artificial Intelligence for Legal Professionals

Juan Pavón,María Jesús González-Espejo
An Introductory Guide to Artificial Intelligence for Legal Professionals Book PDF

Author : Juan Pavón,María Jesús González-Espejo
Publisher : Kluwer Law International B.V.
Page : 301 pages
File Size : 40,8 Mb
Release : 2020-05-14
Category : Law
ISBN : 9789403509822

Get Book

An Introductory Guide to Artificial Intelligence for Legal Professionals by Juan Pavón,María Jesús González-Espejo Pdf

The availability of very large data sets and the increase in computing power to process them has led to a renewed intensity in corporate and governmental use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies. This groundbreaking book, the first devoted entirely to the growing presence of AI in the legal profession, responds to the necessity of building up a discipline that due to its novelty requires the pooling of knowledge and experiences of well-respected experts in the AI field, taking into account the impact of AI on the law and legal practice. Essays by internationally known expert authors introduce the essentials of AI in a straightforward and intelligible style, offering jurists as many practical examples and business cases as possible so that they are able to understand the real application of this technology and its impact on their jobs and lives. Elements of the analysis include the following: crucial terms: natural language processing, machine learning and deep learning; regulations in force in major jurisdictions; ethical and social issues; labour and employment issues, including the impact that robots have on employment; prediction of outcome in the legal field (judicial proceedings, patent granting, etc.); massive analysis of documents and identification of patterns from which to derive conclusions; AI and taxation; issues of competition and intellectual property; liability and responsibility of intelligent systems; AI and cybersecurity; AI and data protection; impact on state tax revenues; use of autonomous killer robots in the military; challenges related to privacy; the need to embrace transparency and sustainability; pressure brought by clients on prices; minority languages and AI; danger that the existing gap between large and small businesses will further increase; how to avoid algorithmic biases when AI decides; AI application to due diligence; AI and non-disclosure agreements; and the role of chatbots. Interviews with pioneers in the field are included, so readers get insights into the issues that people are dealing with in day-to-day actualities. Whether conceiving AI as a transformative technology of the labour market and training or an economic and business sector in need of legal advice, this introduction to AI will help practitioners in tax law, labour law, competition law and intellectual property law understand what AI is, what it serves, what is the state of the art and the potential of this technology, how they can benefit from its advantages and what are the risks it presents. As the global economy continues to suffer the repercussions of a framework that was previously fundamentally self-regulatory, policymakers will recognize the urgent need to formulate rules to properly manage the future of AI.

Artificial Intelligence and Normative Challenges

Angelos Kornilakis,Georgios Nouskalis,Vassilis Pergantis,Themistoklis Tzimas
Artificial Intelligence and Normative Challenges Book PDF

Author : Angelos Kornilakis,Georgios Nouskalis,Vassilis Pergantis,Themistoklis Tzimas
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 274 pages
File Size : 47,5 Mb
Release : 2023-11-20
Category : Law
ISBN : 9783031410819

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence and Normative Challenges by Angelos Kornilakis,Georgios Nouskalis,Vassilis Pergantis,Themistoklis Tzimas Pdf

Artificial intelligence (AI) – both in its current, comparatively limited form and even more so in its potential future forms (such as general and superintelligence) – has raised both concerns and hopes. Its actual and potential consequences are increasingly far-reaching, affecting almost every facet of human life on a collective and individual level: from the use of mobile phones and social media to autonomous weapons, and from the digitalization of knowledge and information to the patentability of AI innovations, unexpected philosophical, ontological, political and legal questions continue to arise.This book offers an insightful and essential guide to the scientific questions that are shaping humanity’s present and future. Presenting a collection of academic essays written by prominent scholars, it addresses the major legal issues concerning AI: its impact on a wide range of human behavior and the general legal response, including questions on AI and legal personhood; responsibility, liability and culpability in the age of AI; the challenges AI poses for intellectual property regimes; human rights challenges; and AI’s impact on jus ad bellum and jus in bello.Given its scope, the book will appeal to researchers, scholars and practitioners seeking a guide to this rapidly transforming landscape.

Artificial Intelligence

Kerrigan, Charles
Artificial Intelligence Book PDF

Author : Kerrigan, Charles
Publisher : Edward Elgar Publishing
Page : 608 pages
File Size : 48,7 Mb
Release : 2022-03-17
Category : Law
ISBN : 9781800371729

Get Book

Artificial Intelligence by Kerrigan, Charles Pdf

This timely book provides an extensive overview and analysis of the law and regulation as it applies to the technology and uses of Artificial Intelligence (AI). It examines the human and ethical concerns associated with the technology, the history of AI and AI in commercial contexts.

AI Approaches to the Complexity of Legal Systems - Models and Ethical Challenges for Legal Systems, Legal Language and Legal Ontologies, Argumentation and Software Agents

Monica Palmirani,Ugo Pagallo,Pompeu Casanovas,Giovanni Sartor
AI Approaches to the Complexity of Legal Systems Models and Ethical Challenges for Legal Systems Legal Language and Legal Ontologies Argumentation and Software Agents Book PDF

Author : Monica Palmirani,Ugo Pagallo,Pompeu Casanovas,Giovanni Sartor
Publisher : Springer
Page : 309 pages
File Size : 51,6 Mb
Release : 2012-11-28
Category : Computers
ISBN : 9783642357312

Get Book

AI Approaches to the Complexity of Legal Systems - Models and Ethical Challenges for Legal Systems, Legal Language and Legal Ontologies, Argumentation and Software Agents by Monica Palmirani,Ugo Pagallo,Pompeu Casanovas,Giovanni Sartor Pdf

The inspiring idea of this workshop series, Artificial Intelligence Approaches to the Complexity of Legal Systems (AICOL), is to develop models of legal knowledge concerning organization, structure, and content in order to promote mutual understanding and communication between different systems and cultures. Complexity and complex systems describe recent developments in AI and law, legal theory, argumentation, the Semantic Web, and multi-agent systems. Multisystem and multilingual ontologies provide an important opportunity to integrate different trends of research in AI and law, including comparative legal studies. Complexity theory, graph theory, game theory, and any other contributions from the mathematical disciplines can help both to formalize the dynamics of legal systems and to capture relations among norms. Cognitive science can help the modeling of legal ontology by taking into account not only the formal features of law but also social behaviour, psychology, and cultural factors. This book is thus meant to support scholars in different areas of science in sharing knowledge and methodological approaches. This volume collects the contributions to the workshop's third edition, which took place as part of the 25th IVR congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, held in Frankfurt, Germany, in August 2011. This volume comprises six main parts devoted to the each of the six topics addressed in the workshop, namely: models for the legal system ethics and the regulation of ICT, legal knowledge management, legal information for open access, software agent systems in the legal domain, as well as legal language and legal ontology.

Regulating Artificial Intelligence

Thomas Wischmeyer,Timo Rademacher
Regulating Artificial Intelligence Book PDF

Author : Thomas Wischmeyer,Timo Rademacher
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 391 pages
File Size : 49,6 Mb
Release : 2019-11-29
Category : Law
ISBN : 9783030323615

Get Book

Regulating Artificial Intelligence by Thomas Wischmeyer,Timo Rademacher Pdf

This book assesses the normative and practical challenges for artificial intelligence (AI) regulation, offers comprehensive information on the laws that currently shape or restrict the design or use of AI, and develops policy recommendations for those areas in which regulation is most urgently needed. By gathering contributions from scholars who are experts in their respective fields of legal research, it demonstrates that AI regulation is not a specialized sub-discipline, but affects the entire legal system and thus concerns all lawyers. Machine learning-based technology, which lies at the heart of what is commonly referred to as AI, is increasingly being employed to make policy and business decisions with broad social impacts, and therefore runs the risk of causing wide-scale damage. At the same time, AI technology is becoming more and more complex and difficult to understand, making it harder to determine whether or not it is being used in accordance with the law. In light of this situation, even tech enthusiasts are calling for stricter regulation of AI. Legislators, too, are stepping in and have begun to pass AI laws, including the prohibition of automated decision-making systems in Article 22 of the General Data Protection Regulation, the New York City AI transparency bill, and the 2017 amendments to the German Cartel Act and German Administrative Procedure Act. While the belief that something needs to be done is widely shared, there is far less clarity about what exactly can or should be done, or what effective regulation might look like. The book is divided into two major parts, the first of which focuses on features common to most AI systems, and explores how they relate to the legal framework for data-driven technologies, which already exists in the form of (national and supra-national) constitutional law, EU data protection and competition law, and anti-discrimination law. In the second part, the book examines in detail a number of relevant sectors in which AI is increasingly shaping decision-making processes, ranging from the notorious social media and the legal, financial and healthcare industries, to fields like law enforcement and tax law, in which we can observe how regulation by AI is becoming a reality.

Beyond Data

Alessandro Mantelero
Beyond Data Book PDF

Author : Alessandro Mantelero
Publisher : Springer Nature
Page : 215 pages
File Size : 55,9 Mb
Release : 2022-06-08
Category : Law
ISBN : 9789462655317

Get Book

Beyond Data by Alessandro Mantelero Pdf

This open access book focuses on the impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on individuals and society from a legal perspective, providing a comprehensive risk-based methodological framework to address it. Building on the limitations of data protection in dealing with the challenges of AI, the author proposes an integrated approach to risk assessment that focuses on human rights and encompasses contextual social and ethical values. The core of the analysis concerns the assessment methodology and the role of experts in steering the design of AI products and services by business and public bodies in the direction of human rights and societal values. Taking into account the ongoing debate on AI regulation, the proposed assessment model also bridges the gap between risk-based provisions and their real-world implementation. The central focus of the book on human rights and societal values in AI and the proposed solutions will make it of interest to legal scholars, AI developers and providers, policy makers and regulators. Alessandro Mantelero is Associate Professor of Private Law and Law & Technology in the Department of Management and Production Engineering at the Politecnico di Torino in Turin, Italy.

Robotics, AI and the Future of Law

Marcelo Corrales,Mark Fenwick,Nikolaus Forgó
Robotics AI and the Future of Law Book PDF

Author : Marcelo Corrales,Mark Fenwick,Nikolaus Forgó
Publisher : Springer
Page : 237 pages
File Size : 42,5 Mb
Release : 2018-11-02
Category : Law
ISBN : 9789811328749

Get Book

Robotics, AI and the Future of Law by Marcelo Corrales,Mark Fenwick,Nikolaus Forgó Pdf

Artificial intelligence and related technologies are changing both the law and the legal profession. In particular, technological advances in fields ranging from machine learning to more advanced robots, including sensors, virtual realities, algorithms, bots, drones, self-driving cars, and more sophisticated “human-like” robots are creating new and previously unimagined challenges for regulators. These advances also give rise to new opportunities for legal professionals to make efficiency gains in the delivery of legal services. With the exponential growth of such technologies, radical disruption seems likely to accelerate in the near future. This collection brings together a series of contributions by leading scholars in the newly emerging field of artificial intelligence, robotics, and the law. The aim of the book is to enrich legal debates on the social meaning and impact of this type of technology. The distinctive feature of the contributions presented in this edition is that they address the impact of these technological developments in a number of different fields of law and from the perspective of diverse jurisdictions. Moreover, the authors utilize insights from multiple related disciplines, in particular social theory and philosophy, in order to better understand and address the legal challenges created by AI. Therefore, the book will contribute to interdisciplinary debates on disruptive new AI technologies and the law.

LAW, TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION

Leonardo Parentoni,Renato César Cardoso
LAW TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION Book PDF

Author : Leonardo Parentoni,Renato César Cardoso
Publisher : Expert Editora
Page : 349 pages
File Size : 41,9 Mb
Release : 2021
Category : Business & Economics
ISBN : 9786599377907

Get Book

LAW, TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION by Leonardo Parentoni,Renato César Cardoso Pdf

his book is part of the collection sponsored by the Brazilian Research Center on Law, Technology and Innovation – DTIBR, a private nonprofit interdisciplinary membership association that works to bridge academia and business, as well as publishing papers and books focused on cutting edge technologies and their legal aspects. The book assembles the best papers from the students, properly revised, in expanded and updated versions. Invited coauthors from other top-ranked universities in Brazil, as well as foreign scholars, also shared their thoughts, experience and impressions about that important subject. In the following pages, the reader will find 13 texts about many aspects of AI technology, not only in the legal field but also from the perspective of other areas, such as ethics, philosophy, computer sciences, medicine, civil law, business law, privacy and personal data protection.

Future Law, Ethics, and Smart Technologies

Anonim
Future Law Ethics and Smart Technologies Book PDF

Author : Anonim
Publisher : BRILL
Page : 322 pages
File Size : 48,9 Mb
Release : 2023-10-20
Category : Philosophy
ISBN : 9789004682900

Get Book

Future Law, Ethics, and Smart Technologies by Anonim Pdf

This interdisciplinary textbook serves as a solid introduction to the future of legal education against the background of the widespread use of AI written by colleagues from different disciplines, e.g. law, philosophy/ethics, economy, and computer science, whose common interest concerns AI and its impact on legal and ethical issues. The book provides, first, a general overview of the effects of AI on major disciplines such as ethics, law, economy, political science, and healthcare. Secondly, it offers a comprehensive analysis of major key issues concerning law: (a) AI decision-making, (b) rights, status, and responsibility, (c) regulation and standardisation, and (d) education.